Corrosion protection for offshore gearboxes: coating to ISO 12944 (C5-M, CX), materials, seals, breathers and maintenance, with sources.
AI This article was created with the help of AI.
Table of contents
- Offshore gearboxes: corrosion protection in salt air and spray
- Coating to ISO 12944: C5-M, C5 and CX
- Materials: stainless steel, duplex and aluminium bronze
- Seals, breathers and lubricant
- Maintenance, condition monitoring and evidence
- Applications and electric motors with protective coating
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
Offshore gearboxes: corrosion protection in salt air and spray
Offshore gearboxes work in salt air, spray and in constant alternation between wet and dry. Corrosion protection for offshore gearboxes rests on four building blocks: corrosion-resistant coatings, suitable materials, sealed housings with dry breathing and maintenance that finds damage early. This article deals with gearbox units above water, with protective coatings for electric motors on the gearbox and with the question of what has become of the former class C5-M. Brakes and their corrosion-resistant coatings are covered in the article offshore brakes: corrosion protection for winches and shafts; gearboxes that run permanently under water are covered in the article on underwater gearboxes.
The environment is most aggressive in the splash zone: wetting and drying alternate frequently, a lot of salt is deposited, and oxygen is plentiful. The rust layer is usually porous and adheres poorly, and the rust products themselves intensify the attack[1]. Near the sea, bimetallic corrosion between different materials is also considerably more likely than in a rural atmosphere[2], and temperature changes produce condensation inside[3].
A standard gearbox is designed for its normal environment. Whether it is suitable offshore depends on whether coating, materials, seals and breather suit the environment, not on the design type alone.
Coating to ISO 12944: C5-M, C5 and CX
ISO 12944 governs the corrosion protection of steel structures by coating systems; Part 9 covers coating systems and laboratory tests for offshore structures[4][5]. Whether an operator requires it for a gearbox housing belongs in the requirements specification.
Anyone looking for a C5-M coating means the earlier edition of the standard, in which C5 was divided into C5(I) for industrial and C5(M) for marine environments. The revision of 2017/18 abolished C5(M); C5 now stands only for very highly corrosive environments on land. For offshore structures, the new category CX (extreme offshore) applies, and ISO 20340 was absorbed into ISO 12944 as Part 9. The reason: the mild test scope of C5(M) allowed systems in extremely harsh offshore environments and led to damage[6]. A “C5-M” entry in an older data sheet is therefore not comparable with CX.
| Category | Environment according to ISO 12944 | Note |
|---|---|---|
| C5 | Very highly corrosive environment on land[6] | Formerly divided into C5(I) and C5(M) |
| CX | Extreme offshore[6] | Part 9, stricter qualification |
| Im4 | Immersion in sea or brackish water with cathodic protection[6] | Together with CX the basis of Part 9[5] |
The durability, from low to very high, is not a warranty period but a planning figure up to the first major maintenance; it depends, among other things, on surface preparation and the condition of edges and welds[6]. There is no blanket coating thickness: since the revision, the minimum coating thicknesses in ISO 12944-5 are binding and depend on system, durability and category; CX is covered by Part 9[6]. Part 9 applies to carbon steel from 3 mm thickness[5]. NORSOK M-501 governs the selection, preparation, application and testing of coatings in the construction and installation of offshore and coastal facilities and recommends systems that reach the high durability level according to ISO 12944-1[7].
Materials: stainless steel, duplex and aluminium bronze
For stainless steels, the pitting resistance equivalent number (PREN) serves as a comparison value for resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion; for duplex steels it is PREN = %Cr + 3.3 × %Mo + 16 × %N[8]. The Informationsstelle Edelstahl Rostfrei stresses that it is an empirically found rule without defined boundary conditions and applies to the atmospheric range at non-elevated temperature. The nitrogen factor depends on the steel group: 16 for duplex steels, 30 for the other grades with at least 3% molybdenum, 0 for grades with less[9]. Values calculated with a different factor are therefore not directly comparable.
Duplex steels have a microstructure of ferrite and austenite and are more resistant to chloride and stronger than standard austenitic grades such as 304 or 316[8]. TWI classifies them by PREN: duplex below 40, super duplex 40 to 45[8]; Wikipedia gives 28 to 38 and 38 to 45[10]. Typical grades are 1.4462 (duplex) and 1.4410 (super duplex)[8][10]. In super duplex, the high alloy contents promote intermetallic phases, which can greatly reduce impact toughness[10]. Stainless does not mean seawater-resistant, however:
| Type of attack | What happens | Consequence for the design |
|---|---|---|
| Crevice corrosion | Even stainless CrNi steels corrode in narrow crevices without oxygen[11] | Avoid crevices or make them wide (DIN EN 12502-4: over 0.5 mm), otherwise seal with plastic[11] |
| Stress corrosion cracking | Cracks under tensile stress in a specific medium; austenitic steels are at risk from chlorides[12] | Chloride is hardly avoidable offshore; consider material and tensile stresses together[12] |
| Bimetallic corrosion | The less noble of two wetted materials in contact is corroded away[13] | A small, less noble part next to a large, more noble one is at risk; near the sea, additional measures where applicable[13] |
Depending on the alloy, aluminium bronze is regarded as resistant to seawater and cavitation and is used, among other things, for bearings, worms, worm wheels and gears[14].
Seals, breathers and lubricant
Water in the gearbox damages oil and bearings. Free water causes rust; according to a frequently cited relationship (Cantley, ASLE 1977), the life of rolling bearings with water above the saturation limit can drop to about 50% of the expected life. The figure comes from a study with an oil of class ISO VG 68 and is a guide, not a value for every gearbox[15].
Radial shaft seals rest with the sealing lip on the rotating shaft, a dust lip is optional; axial shaft seals protect as a secondary seal against dust and spray. Usual materials are NBR, H-NBR, FKM and PTFE, FKM where requirements for chemical resistance and heat are higher[16]. A labyrinth seal works without contact and without wear, but is never absolutely tight[17] and therefore on its own is not sufficient as a water barrier.
The breather also plays a part: a desiccant breather instead of a simple cap keeps particles and moisture out of the air drawn in[3]. If the headspace stays dry, the oil releases water; in a pump test, this resulted in a calculated expected bearing life 20 to 40% longer, and the author concludes that bearing sealing and a desiccant breather are needed together to keep bearing life as long as possible[15].
For sensors, breathers and terminal boxes, the protection class counts: digit 6 stands for protection against powerful water jets, digit 8 for continuous immersion. Its conditions are agreed between manufacturer and user unless a product standard specifies them; they must be stricter than for digit 7 (temporary immersion)[18]. The tests behind this are explained in our article on IP69K and IP67 protection classes.
Maintenance, condition monitoring and evidence
A coating lasts only if it is maintained: it should be inspected regularly and small damage should be repaired so that the system reaches its durability up to the first major maintenance[6]. Condition monitoring records vibrations, temperatures and other variables periodically or continuously and enables condition-based rather than fixed maintenance intervals[19]. Since water in the oil causes rust[15], the water content is among the useful parameters to check.
Several documents serve as evidence and rule sets. ISO 12944-7 covers the execution and supervision of the painting work[4]. An inspection certificate 3.1 according to EN 10204 confirms conformity with the order, stating the results of specific inspection by a representative of the manufacturer who is independent of production[20]. The salt spray test according to DIN EN ISO 9227 or ASTM B117 serves for quality control of coatings; its result rarely matches behaviour in a natural environment, however[21].
Classification societies such as DNV or ABS issue construction rules, monitor compliance during construction, check the condition of ships in service and also certify offshore structures[22]. Which requirements apply to a gearbox follows from the rules of the respective society for the specific equipment; ask there early.
Applications and electric motors with protective coating
Typical installation locations are winches, cranes and slewing drives on deck. The environment determines coating, material and sealing, not the gearbox type; the requirements specification names category, durability, protection class and material certificates.
Protective coatings for electric motors on the gearbox follow the same considerations. The housing needs a coating system that suits the environment, attached parts should not form an unfavourable metal pair with it[13], and terminal box and cable entry need a protection class that suits the spray load[18]. Motors that actually submerge are covered in the article on the waterproof motor and underwater motor.
As a supplier of the complete drive train, we at ATEK Drive Solutions design gearbox, motor and brake to match, from a single source. You will find an overview of our gearboxes in our product range; you are welcome to discuss the requirements of your application at sea with us personally via our contact page.
Frequently asked questions
Why are standard gearboxes often unsuitable offshore?
It is not the design type alone that decides, but whether the gearbox is adapted to the environment. Offshore, salt, frequent wetting in the splash zone[1], bimetallic corrosion between materials[2] and condensation after temperature changes[3] come together. The sources examined give no reliable failure or cost figures.
Which materials and coatings are suitable for offshore gearboxes?
For coatings on offshore structures, the benchmark is category CX with the tests according to ISO 12944-9[6][5]. Among metals, duplex and super duplex such as 1.4462 and 1.4410[8] as well as aluminium bronze[14] come into question. The pairing and the design are decisive, not just the individual material[2].
What does C5-M mean, and does the class still apply?
C5-M was the marine subcategory of C5 in the earlier edition of ISO 12944. It was abolished with the revision of 2017/18; C5 now applies only to environments on land, and for offshore structures CX applies[6].
How important is sealing?
Water in the oil causes rust and can reduce bearing life to about half of the expected life[15]. Shaft seals with a dust lip, secondary seals against spray[16] and a desiccant breather[3] work together.
Can condition monitoring save costs on offshore gearboxes?
It replaces fixed maintenance intervals with condition-based maintenance[19]. The sources examined give no reliable percentage for downtime saved. Vibration, temperature and the water content in the oil are useful to monitor[19][15].
Which standards must be observed?
DIN EN 10088-1 for stainless steels[9], ISO 12944 with Part 9 for offshore coatings[5], where applicable NORSOK M-501 for coatings on offshore facilities[7], EN 10204 for inspection certificates[20] and the rules of the classification society for the specific equipment[22].
Sources
- Liu, Li, Hou: Corrosion Behaviour of DH36 Steel Used for Oil Platform in Splash Zones, Corrosion Science and Technology 14 (4), 2015
- Informationsstelle Edelstahl Rostfrei: Merkblatt 829, stainless steel in contact with other materials (in German)
- Plant Services: Extend the life of your gearbox
- Wikipedia (EN): ISO 12944
- Estonian Centre for Standardisation and Accreditation (EVS): EVS-EN ISO 12944-9:2018, description and scope
- Institute of Corrosion (ICorr): ISO 12944-5:2018 – Protective Paint Systems, Setting Coating Specifications for Environment and Durability
- Standards Norway: NORSOK M-501:2022, Surface protection and protective coating
- TWI: Job Knowledge, Duplex stainless steel, Part 1
- Informationsstelle Edelstahl Rostfrei: Merkblatt 820, guidance on selecting stainless steel grades (in German)
- Wikipedia (EN): Duplex stainless steel
- Wikipedia (DE): Spaltkorrosion
- Wikipedia (DE): Spannungsrisskorrosion
- Wikipedia (DE): Bimetallkorrosion
- Wikipedia (DE): Aluminiumbronze
- Precision Lubrication: How to Protect Pumps and Gearboxes by Removing Water from Oil
- Wikipedia (DE): Wellendichtring
- Wikipedia (DE): Labyrinthdichtung
- IEC 60529:1989+A1:1999+A2:2013: Degrees of protection provided by enclosures (IP Code)
- Wikipedia (DE): Condition Monitoring (Zustandsüberwachung)
- Wikipedia (DE): EN 10204
- Wikipedia (DE): Salzsprühtest
- Wikipedia (DE): Klassifikationsgesellschaft