Duty types S1 to S10, thermal classes, PTC thermistors, thermal switches and motor protection circuit breakers: how to protect motors thermally in continuous duty.
AI This article was created with the help of AI.
Table of contents
- Thermally protected motors in continuous duty: S1 to S10
- Thermal classes: how hot the winding may get
- PTC thermistors in the winding
- Thermal switches and Pt100 as alternatives
- Motor protection circuit breakers and overload relays
- Defining the protection concept for continuous duty
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
Thermally protected motors in continuous duty: S1 to S10
Whether a motor reaches its thermal limit depends first of all on its duty type. The standard IEC 60034-1, EN 60034-1 in Europe, distinguishes ten rated duty types. If no duty type is stated on the nameplate, the machine is designed for continuous duty with constant load[1]. In continuous duty S1, the motor runs under load until its temperature no longer changes. There are no pauses in which the winding could cool down. Thermally protected motors in continuous duty must therefore dissipate their heat losses permanently, and any disruption of the cooling has a direct effect on the winding temperature.
| Duty type | Designation | Additional data |
|---|---|---|
| S1 | Continuous running duty with constant load | none |
| S2 | Short-time duty | Load duration |
| S3 | Intermittent periodic duty | Cyclic duration factor in %, based on 10 min |
| S4 | Intermittent periodic duty with starting | Cyclic duration factor, cycles per hour, moment of inertia |
| S5 | as S4, additionally with electric braking | as S4 |
| S6 | Continuous-operation periodic duty | Cyclic duration factor in %, based on 10 min |
| S7 | Continuous-operation periodic duty with electric braking | Cycles per hour, moment of inertia |
| S8 | Continuous-operation periodic duty with load and speed changes | Cycles per hour, moment of inertia |
| S9 | Duty with non-periodic load and speed variations | Cycles per hour, moment of inertia |
| S10 | Duty with discrete constant loads | – |
An example of the difference: a winch motor rated S3 25 % may run for 2.5 minutes in every 10-minute cycle and must cool down in the remaining 7.5 minutes[1]. If you use such a motor in continuous duty, it exceeds its permissible temperature. How to read the frame size, power and nameplate data of standard motors is shown in our article on IEC electric motors.
Thermal classes: how hot the winding may get
The temperature limit of a motor is set by its winding insulation. The insulation or thermal classes are defined in DIN EN 60085; classes F and H are common in industrial motors[2]:
| Thermal class | Temperature limit | Thermal class | Temperature limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Y | 90 °C | F | 155 °C |
| A | 105 °C | H | 180 °C |
| E | 120 °C | N | 200 °C |
| B | 130 °C | R | 220 °C |
The permissible maximum temperature at the hottest point is made up of the rated ambient temperature, often 40 °C, the permissible temperature rise and an allowance of 10 °C for the hot spot[3].
The classes are reference values for the insulation system; the temperature rise a specific motor may reach is stated in its data sheet. For service life, the rule of thumb is that the service life of the insulation halves with every temperature increase of 10 °C[3]. A motor with class F insulation that only heats up to the class B limit during operation therefore has a 25 K reserve, which pays off in a significantly longer winding service life.
The reserve shrinks as soon as the surroundings are warmer than the rated temperature, the cooling fins become dirty or a self-ventilated motor on a frequency converter runs at low speed for a long time, because its fan impeller then turns more slowly. In the latter case, a forced-ventilation fan helps. For locations with very high or very low temperatures, motor, gearbox and lubrication must be designed together, as described in our article on temperature-compensated gear motors.
PTC thermistors in the winding
A widely used form of temperature protection is the PTC thermistor. With so-called full motor protection, several PTC thermistors are connected in series, typically three, which are installed in the poorly cooled or uncooled hot spots of the winding. At the rated response temperature, their resistance rises abruptly, for example to 1.5 kΩ. The evaluation is handled by an external device that switches off the motor contactor via an NC contact at resistance values from about 3,600 to 4,000 Ω and releases it again only below about 1,600 to 1,650 Ω. In addition, short circuits in the sensor cable and wire breaks can be detected. PTC thermistors for motor protection are standardized in DIN 44081 and DIN 44082[4].
The big advantage: the PTC thermistor measures where the insulation ages. It also reacts to causes in which the current remains unremarkable, such as dirty cooling fins, a defective fan or an excessively high ambient temperature. Its limits lie in the heat transfer between winding and sensor:
- The sensors should be located in the winding section with the highest temperature; retrofitting on the end winding should be limited to special cases because of the poor heat transfer.
- Because of the coupling time, the winding temperature at response is always above the rated response temperature.
- At current densities above about 40 A/mm², as can occur with a locked rotor, the winding overshoots by more than 50 K. In that case, the PTC thermistor cannot provide sole protection[5].
The combination with a current-dependent trip unit, which switches off at the locked-rotor current after about 15 s at the latest, is therefore recommended. During testing, the actual response temperature should not deviate by more than ±5 K from the rated response temperature; for continuity measurements, a maximum of 2.5 V AC per sensor is permissible. An insulation tester is therefore not suitable for the continuity test, and during the insulation test of the motor winding, the sensor circuit must be earthed to prevent damage from capacitive charging[5].
Thermal switches and Pt100 as alternatives
Instead of PTC thermistors, many motors have bimetallic switches in the winding, which are used to monitor the winding temperature[4]. Such a thermal switch opens a contact in the control circuit at a fixed temperature and does not need its own evaluation device. However, a single sensor, whether PTC thermistor or bimetallic switch, serves only for general approximate monitoring and is not intended as the sole protective measure[4].
A bimetallic switch usually closes again after cooling down. So that the motor does not then start up uncontrolled, the contact belongs in a control system with a restart lockout. Whether the reset is then automatic or manual only is something you decide based on the hazard: where an unexpected restart can endanger people, for example on conveyor belts, manual acknowledgement with a check of the cause is the right choice. An automatic reset of the protection can lead to the destruction of the plant[4].
A Pt100 resistance thermometer does not switch; it supplies a continuous temperature value. It is suitable if you want to record winding or bearing temperatures continuously, set warning thresholds before shutdown or evaluate trends for maintenance. The shutdown itself is then handled by an evaluation unit with set limit values.
Motor protection circuit breakers and overload relays
Current-dependent protection works indirectly. A motor protection circuit breaker monitors the currents in the three supply lines and switches off the main circuit itself. An overload or motor protection relay works on the same principle but does not switch off the motor directly; instead, it acts on the upstream contactor[4]. A common misconception: the bimetal in the breaker does not measure the temperature of the motor; it models the heating via the current. Electronic trip units measure the current of each line conductor with current transformers and imitate this behaviour[4].
What current-dependent protection achieves and where it reaches its limits:
- It detects mechanical overload and the failure of one or two line conductors. In the motor protection circuit breaker, an electromagnetic trip unit also responds instantaneously to short-circuit currents; a motor protection relay has no short-circuit trip unit and needs upstream fuses[4].
- According to EN 60947, maximum times for overload must be specified; for all set currents, the tripping time must be below the time at which the motor insulation is endangered. A higher ambient temperature at the breaker can bring tripping forward[4].
- A thermal overcurrent trip unit does not represent a thermal image of the winding. At high switching frequencies, it would trip far too early; for intermittent duty S4, a motor with thermistor protection as sole protection is recommended[6].
- Where cooling may be impaired, for example in dusty environments, the standard for hoists, DIN EN 60204-32, recommends motors with built-in thermal protection[6].
For drives with a long run-up, such as large fans or flywheel masses, choose a slow trip class so that the protection tolerates the start and still switches off in the event of a genuine overload. The test button on breakers and relays only actuates the tripping mechanism; it is a purely mechanical test[4] and does not replace a check of the set values.
Defining the protection concept for continuous duty
In continuous duty, the two types of protection complement each other. The overview shows which cause each type of protection reliably detects[5][6]:
| Cause | Temperature sensor in the winding | Current-dependent protection |
|---|---|---|
| slow mechanical overload | yes | yes |
| dirty cooling fins, fan failure | yes | no, current remains normal |
| excessive ambient temperature at the motor | yes | no |
| high switching frequency | yes | unreliable, trips too early |
| locked rotor | too slow at high current densities | yes, fast |
| failure of one line conductor | only indirectly via the heating | yes |
| short circuit | no | yes, via short-circuit trip unit or fuse |
Stricter rules apply to potentially explosive atmospheres: according to EN 60079-14, the motor must be switched off within the time tE stated on the nameplate. Thermistors are permitted there as an alternative to current-dependent trip units, but as sole protection they must also be effective when the machine is locked[7].
A consistent protection concept begins with motor selection: duty type, thermal class, ambient temperature and sensor type belong in the specification, not only in commissioning. As a supplier for the complete drive train, we at ATEK Drive Solutions design motor, gearbox and brake to fit precisely from a single source, including the appropriate temperature sensors in the winding. You will find an overview in our IEC standard motors, and we will be happy to advise you on your application via our contact page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between S1 and S3?
S1 is continuous duty with constant load and no cooling pauses. S3 is intermittent periodic duty: the rating S3 25 % means that the motor may run under load for 2.5 minutes in every 10-minute cycle and must then cool down.
How hot may a motor get in continuous duty?
What matters is the winding, not the housing. Its maximum temperature is determined by the thermal class: 130 °C for class B, 155 °C for class F and 180 °C for class H. A warm housing is normal in continuous duty; the permissible values are given in the data sheet.
What do insulation classes F and H mean?
They denote the thermal capability of the insulation system according to DIN EN 60085: class F is designed for up to 155 °C and class H for up to 180 °C at the hottest point. Both classes are common in industrial motors.
Is a motor protection circuit breaker sufficient in continuous duty?
With clean cooling, an ambient temperature within the rated range and few starts, often yes. However, it does not detect dirty cooling fins, a failed fan or an excessive ambient temperature, because the current remains unchanged in these cases. That requires temperature sensors in the winding.
When does a manual reset after a protective shutdown make sense?
Whenever an automatic restart can endanger people or the machine, for example on conveyor belts or open drives. Manual acknowledgement ensures that the cause is checked before the motor runs again.
What is the thermal time constant of a motor?
It describes how quickly a motor heats up or cools down. At standstill, self-ventilated motors lack ventilation, so the cooling time constant is several times longer than during operation. After a protective shutdown, it accordingly takes time before the motor may start again.
Which standards are relevant for thermal motor protection?
IEC/EN 60034-1 for the duty types, DIN EN 60085 for the thermal classes, DIN 44081 and DIN 44082 for PTC thermistors, IEC 60034-11 for built-in thermal protection and EN 60947 for motor protection circuit breakers and relays. In potentially explosive atmospheres, EN 60079-14 is added.
What applies at extreme ambient temperatures such as –40 to +100 °C, and who designs such drives?
The rated data of a motor often refer to an ambient temperature of 40 °C. If it is higher, the temperature reserve of the winding decreases, and the power or thermal class must be adjusted. At low temperatures, lubricant, seals and the starting behaviour of motor and gearbox come to the fore. For such applications, you should therefore have motor, gearbox and lubrication designed together by one supplier. As a supplier for the complete drive train, ATEK Drive Solutions designs motor and gearbox from a single source and clarifies the permissible temperature range for your application on a case-by-case basis.
Sources
- Wikipedia (DE): Nennbetriebsart (rated duty type)
- Wikipedia (DE): Isolierstoffklasse (insulation class)
- Wikipedia (EN): Insulation system
- Wikipedia (DE): Motorschutz (motor protection)
- elektropraktiker.de (DE): Possibilities and limits of motor protection with thermistors
- elektropraktiker.de (DE): Protection of three-phase drives for hoists
- elektropraktiker.de (DE): ATEX requirements for motor protection devices